In life, we all suffer through humiliation rituals: a public fart, a wardrobe malfunction, running into the last person you want to see while wearing yesterday’s outfit, and, if you grew up in the 2000s, the JCPenney Portrait Studio.
Like most things, humiliations don’t change. They evolve.
Let me take you back to the early 2000s. Less than five years removed from 9/11, the Staten Island Mall was a safe haven, a place to forget your fears and cut loose. Except for one day a year, somewhere around Easter, when my parents took us to JCPenney to get our portraits taken.
You see, as a kid, there were three things I really didn’t like: green food, haircuts, and taking pictures. Haircuts are the only thing on that list I’ve grown to love.
It’s important to note that my mother was not a dictator. For the most part, she let us wear whatever we wanted when offering our image and likeness to the good people of JCPenney. Somewhere in the family archives, there’s a portrait of me wearing a Pokémon sweater vest.
But we always had to get the shot.
We didn’t have a ceremonious end to our run at JCPenney, though. I’m pretty sure we were asked to leave.
Let me introduce my sister, Sophia. Five years younger than me, she was a blonde-haired, blue-eyed hurricane of a child.
Dressed in her yellow Easter dress, white shirt, and bonnet, Sophia refused to put down her snacks. She held on tight.
She refused to be humiliated.
That is something I’ve always admired about her.
Imagine the scene. On Staten Island, the portrait lady has more power than the borough president. And there she was, Little Bo Peep, Cookie Monster snacks and all.
My parents simply had her take the pictures, and then we left, never to return or grace the walls of the portrait studio on the lower level of the Staten Island JCPenney, right by the bathrooms, again.
At least that’s how I remembered it.
After consulting my mother, I’ve learned that I had the right story, just the wrong year.
Apparently, Sophia’s cookies actually saved the shoot. She was tired and hungry. My parents gave her the snacks, she batted her eyes and smiled, and JCPenney got their shot.
My sister, the little monster she was, looked like a cherub, snacks in hand.
It was the following year that the wheels came off. The portrait lady lost patience with Sophia, and my mother lost hers with the portrait lady, so we took our talents to The Picture People. They had a fire truck.
My mother also informed me that, despite my lifelong aversion to photographs, I was actually a good sport. I’ve decided not to contest this.
And now we get to hear from the star of the show. Oh, how she’ll relish me calling her that. My little sister, Sophia.
She remembers a bluish-gray room and what she believes was a bossy woman. The finer details are hazy, but her position on the cookies remains firm.
“I don’t remember specifically saying that I didn’t want to let go of the cookies, but I know they never left my hand. I just knew it was my business to keep them there.”
When asked whether she stands by her decision, she didn’t hesitate.
“I stand by my decision to hold onto the cookies. It’s just a representation of the kind of kid I was and the kind of adult I am now. I am the baby sister, and baby sister gets her way.”
There was more to these trips than the pictures. School pictures were in the fall, so we got portraits around Easter for my grandmother, followed by lunch and a trip to KB Toys. What I remember as an itchy humiliation ritual was apparently a day filled with toys, chicken nuggets, and ice cream.
As for what we wore, my mother had a simple philosophy.
“We were never Foo-Foo people,” she told me.
She let us pick from a few different “casual Friday” looks while other families arrived in their Sunday best, something she considered too unnatural for our lifestyle.
We’ve moved the photoshoot out of the lower level of JCPenney and into every other corner of our lives, but the urge to dress like somebody else for the occasion is alive and well.
Everyone you know is getting professionally photographed. Engagements, weddings, and all the white-picket-fence events you can imagine.
I love it. Have a ball. Commemorate your moment.
I’m not a bad guy, I like fun.
But stop dressing like a mannequin.
As the self-appointed #1 menswear guy, I feel obligated to weigh in. A relatively unimportant thing to be #1 at, but better than being #3 or, worse, #2.
Take the Carbon Copy. He’s dressed as the masculine version of his partner.
The outfit was just pressed and laid out, tags still attached. Why is it there? It matches, it looked good somewhere else, and it could arrive on time.
Most likely not even tried on. Another catastrophe is looming. Poor fit, commemorated and shared in a joint IG post.
You’re wearing clothes you’d never wear, taking pictures in something as foreign to you as being dressed as a Ninja Turtle.
The overall aesthetic is, “This is fine. No one’s really looking at you anyway.”
...I am looking.
Then there’s the Course Pro.
The best clothes he owns are the ones he golfs in. Expensive polos, pants that fit, an unfrayed belt.
Keep them on the course.
Your family portrait doesn’t need to be a monument to your $300 tee time.
Finally, the Logo Liaison.
You know the kind. Every article of clothing is another opportunity to announce his perceived affluence. Gucci down to the socks.
This is one of the most contagious mistakes. Before you know it, the whole family is dripped down in logos. You just look tacky. And don’t get me started on the brands not matching.
On his own, he isn’t much better. Everyone else is dressed to the nines, and he’s in a Balenciaga hoodie. You just look dumb.
Wearing the most expensive thing you own is usually not the answer.
As for the Logo Liaison, there is no known cure. You can only hope the illness fades.
In a test to see just how sick I really am, I reached out to my friend Dylan, who professionally photographs all those white-picket-fence events.
He told me couples often buy entirely new outfits for engagement shoots, but he doesn’t think unfamiliar clothing necessarily translates into visible discomfort. Fit and confidence are what really come through on camera.
And he’s right. Proper posing and patience are just as important as the outfit. Having been photographed by him, I know he has plenty of both.
Could I be projecting years of perceived humiliation and confusing taste for comfort? It’s possible.
But as a clothes-obsessed weirdo, I can’t help noticing when an outfit looks like it was chosen for the photograph rather than the person wearing it.
But don’t fret... I can fix you.
These shoots are usually planned way ahead of time. Act accordingly. Don’t run to the mall the day of or buy whatever can arrive on time. Think about what you want to wear. Not just what colors match, but what feels good, natural, and what you actually want to be seen in.
If it’s really a look you want to explore, break it in before bringing it to set. A wise woman once said, “You can’t compete on new skates.”
And get your haircut. I love haircut day as much as the next guy, but give it a few days to settle. The absolute luxury is a haircut three to five days before, followed by a shape-up the day of.
Is it overkill? Yes. Will you thank me? With a kiss on the mouth.
Natural fabrics with some drape go a long way. Your sweat-wicking clothes have a habit of leaving you with your headlights on or your undershirt lines showing. It doesn’t matter what shape you’re in.
Keep the style. There’s nothing wrong with a polo and pants that fit. Just change the fabric. Word to the wise, though: polos are some of the least forgiving tops to be photographed in, regardless of fabric. Take a few test pictures on your phone before diving in.
An outfit can photograph well and still be wrong for the occasion. Not everything belongs everywhere. My most-worn items are things I wouldn’t wear to a frolicking family shoot.
I’ve already given my sermon on dressing for an occasion in The Art of the Good Boy Fit.
And if you’re buying something new, ask yourself: Is this something you’re going to keep wearing afterward, or is it a one-and-done?
If it’s a one-and-done, fine. I’ve bought a shirt for a party, never to be worn again. But remember, even if the clothes are gone, the evidence remains. The pictures will be printed, framed, posted to the grid, and admired for years to come.
Sophia and her snacks have been proudly displayed in my mom’s living room for over twenty years. According to Sophia, the ladies have always gone crazy for the picture.
She maintains that perfect families are boring and that the photograph is a perfect representation of ours.
She also considers it evidence of a great injustice: “the opportunity for me to be a child star was stripped away.”
If you ask me, it serves as the living room’s Mona Lisa, while my portraits are The Wedding Feast at Cana.
–SP








The first miracle of Jesus hmmmmm