We have entered one of the best times of year to flex those dressing muscles. Layering, knits, and occasions out the ass. Now that everyone’s JFK Jr. Halloween costume is off, we approach the first stop on the end-of-year dressing circuit.
Thanksgiving.
Thanksgiving brings names and faces not seen since last year’s holiday circuit. And unlike Christmas, which brings the comfort of pajamas, Thanksgiving comes with the expectation that your hair will be done, your shoes will be shined, and your shirt will be pressed.
Our first pothole. Looking good runs in complete opposition to the day’s main event: firsts, seconds, and if you’re a big strong boy like me, thirds.
You might only see these people twice a year, but you want them to remember you as the best-dressed person the family tree has ever seen. Not the guy who fell asleep on the couch with his gut hanging out before halftime.
As we go over the river and through the woods in our Sunday best, we must think about how we structure our outfits. Start with the pants. More importantly, the waistband.
You cannot look like a schlep. Your aunt is going to be there, so sweats are off the table. But this is not the day for your stomach-flu pants. Wear your tried-and-true, I-know-these-work pants.
A waistband with some give, still attached to a real pair of pants. A pleat or two if you want to show people you really do this and give yourself some room to breathe.
You must be prepared to carry chairs, Cha Cha Slide, and maybe run a route. A split down the ass during apps could be detrimental to family morale or make you a running joke for years to come.
DON’T FORGET YOUR BELT!
From our roomy, yet handsome foundation, we build upward. Like an onion, we’re going to have layers, and every one has to look good and serve its purpose.
The temperature at group gorgings is known to be hostile. Open windows. Ovens on for days on end. Everyone on top of each other. And don’t get me started on the hugging.
Apply some antiperspirant, and lay off the cologne. There will be enough smells without your Byredo.
Starting closest to the nip and building out, we have your undershirt. It’s important. Don’t skip this part.
There’s a possibility you may have to strip down. You never know if you’ll be volunteered for a garage task, handed a particularly messy stack of dishes, or pulled into a game of touch. The last thing you want is an ill-fitting shirt or a peculiar stain ruining everyone’s appetites.
“YOUR MOTHER SPENT ALL WEEK COOKING.”
Next up, the freezer shirt. The piece with the most walking-around money, and the one most likely to end up wearing gravy.
An inside baseball tip: If you show up early to prep, keep it on ice until company has arrived and the apron is off.
Why a freezer shirt, you ask? I had a buddy in school who used to put his shirt for the night in the freezer until people started showing up to the party. Some people are just next-level thinkers.
Your options are likely one of three things: a button-down or button-up, a knit, or a polo.
I’ve ranted about polos recently. I’m not doing it again. Leave your Easter colors at home, and I would try a long-sleeve one. A cozier look for the fall days, and it makes you look more dressed up. I like them.
Buttons are most likely going to be your safest option. It’s very hard to offend someone in a shirt with buttons. Most guys there will probably be in some autumn gingham or plaid.
Be prepared that your niche flannel is for you, and that’s fine. Keep the crown on your head.
Your sweater can be a winner here. Who doesn’t love a handsome knit on Turkey Day? But be warned: go too heavy and your internal temperature starts to rise.
If the buttons are begging for mercy, the polo is ready for 18, or the knit is frayed and pilled—put it down.
Here comes my favorite, the optional menswear guy layer. Something that will be taken off at some point during the party, but not thrown in with the coats in the master bedroom. It’s for you, maybe a few other menswear people, but really, it’s for you.
A chore coat, overshirt, cardigan, or lightweight jacket. You also have the option of a sweater here. Just make sure you’re not banking on it to cover up an issue with your main layer. Nothing worse than showing your ass halfway through the party.
Proceed with caution. A glass of red may end up on it, or a drunk uncle may take it home. High-risk, high-reward layering play.
Last and kind of least, the arriving layer. Most people won’t see it. Do what you want here. This is about warmth, not agony. Unless you’re like me.
It could be your North Face from seventh grade, but it’s long coat season, baby, and I have a few that have been burning a hole in my closet.
Footwear is a family-by-family case. Are you going to a shoes-off house? Do you guys get active? Or are we dressing to impress?
On the feet, KISS. Odds are, your shoes are going to end up in a pile someone trips over.
I have my 3sixteen square-toe boots pegged for Thanksgiving, even if my shoes will be coming off.
A few rules for socks: No holes, no stains, no weed leaves.
This is what I should paywall.
What really separates the players from the pimps: your Break-in-Case Bag.
Coming early to help set up or staying late to clean up? Pack some comfortable clothes. You don’t want to break a sweat before the people get there, and you’re going to want to let it all out when they leave. You’ll thank me on the ride home.
Plan on getting involved in the yard, but want to wear your good shoes for the fit pic? Pack some sneakers and a change of socks. You don’t want your church shoes in the mud, or to spend the ride home in sweaty socks.
On a day like this, a few things are non-negotiable when leaving the crib. Tums to keep the machine moving. A Tide pen for the errant splatter, splash, or spill. Gum, because you’re going to be up close and personal. It’s just as good to offer as it is to chew. Deodorant because sometimes you need to powder your pits.
And maybe a digestive pack of cigs as well.
Gospel still not convincing? I can almost guarantee that pictures of you you’ll never see will end up on Facebook, so the fit might as well be hard.
Happy Thanksgiving. Send in your Turkey Day fit pics. Hope you don’t look like a float, and gear up for the next leg of the circuit: the office Christmas party.
-SP





Church shoes or sweats? What are you wearing to the annual gorging?