We all dress as a form of expression—a statement about how we want to be viewed, a declaration of how much we care or don’t care. Too often, we let the brands we wear do the heavy lifting.
We find something we like and stop looking. The label becomes enough of a reason to buy. A security blanket.
That’s brand rot. Guilty as charged.
Would you still want it if you didn’t know who made it? Or are you getting off on having a cool brand when you fit check in the group chat?
My ears perk up when my boy drops a new brand in the chat and gives me something new to covet. That doesn’t mean it should get my money automatically.
Peter Millar
“The devil wears Peter Millar.” Bow down to the crown.
The Peter Millar man thinks he stands out in a sea of Peter Millar because he paid retail for his.
At one point, I thought Peter Millar made some of the best stuff I owned. I was younger and had money to burn. They sold it at Nordstrom, and it was expensive. It had to be good, right?
And for golf, why not? It’s when the clubhouse uniform follows you back to the office that you lose me. $110 for a performance polo to perform Excel formulas in.
You want people to think you dress well, and I’m here to help.
What I’d wear instead
For outerwear, swap the Peter Millar for a waxed Barbour. It’ll age better.
For polos, stick with cotton. Ralph Lauren if you want to keep a logo. Go with the classic mesh polo and you’ll never look back at the pony and wonder what you were thinking.
If you’re looking for an upgrade without an announcement, take a look at Beams Plus.
Both polos will look better with jeans. The stretchy ones just don’t look good in pictures. Add a jacket and you look like you showed up somewhere with a dress code and borrowed one from the lost and found.
And when someone asks what you’re wearing, hitting them with “Beams” is much cooler than “Peter Millar.” I know you want them to ask.
Vineyard Vines
This is where you can find the most evidence on me. The half-decade I spent in college was whaled out to the max. It was hands down my most-worn and favorite brand. To this day, I credit myself with bringing it to Staten Island, a place untouched by any prep trend for most of its history.
I thought I was him. Button-downs, tees, an overpriced bottle opener that’s terrible to use. I wanted people to know how chill and well dressed I was.
I wore this stuff into the ground—not because I liked it forever, but because it was all I had. I’ll never part with my worn-through pink Shep Shirt, the only remnant I have from that time. It’s a memento of who I was. I’m happy to report the whale no longer has a hold on me.
What I’d wear instead
I guess J.Crew, if you’re looking for prep. But this is more a lesson in not buying something because you think the logo means something about who you want to be.
Not every day should feel that good.
Buck Mason
So I’m going to be real: I’ve never bought anything from Buck Mason, tried any of it on, or walked into a store to experience the catnipping they appear to be doing to men of a certain age.
I could be wrong. I don’t think I am.
My FYP is full of men doing fit checks, all in Buck, acting like they invented fire—and people ranting against them.
The pitch is good: faithful recreations, clean, logo-free clothes, a true boutique experience. You’re no longer buying the second-cheapest bottle of wine on the list. You’ve done some research.
Apparently, knowing where everything came from is enough to feel validated in an expensive purchase.
Military clothing is one of the building blocks of modern menswear. There’s a lot to explore. What makes this store’s version the one you want?
If the name is doing all the convincing, you’re no different from the Peter Millar guy.
What I’d wear instead
If you’re bucked down to your drawers, I probably can’t change your mind. But if you’re willing to spend that much on your clothes, start by buying your next piece somewhere else.
But who knows? Maybe I’ll pop into one, grab a shoulder massage and a glass of whisky, and see what all the hubbub is about.
Our Legacy
Well, we’ve reached the accountability portion of the evening.
I do this.
As I type this, I’m wearing Camion boots I can’t ever seem to fully break in. Our Legacy is probably the brand that eats up the largest portion of my clothing budget. It’s my default “I want to buy something” brand.
Do I enjoy the clothes? Yes. Did I need to buy sweats from them with no pockets because they were on sale? No.
What I’d wear instead
Probably more Our Legacy. But I should probably pause before buying any more.
-SP.
Who did I miss, what am I wrong about, and which brands have you done this with?



